Logo Fracsima DISROC Examples DISROC

DISROC 5 -  Example: Other Examples

Fracture propagation in heterogeneous materials

The example of heterogeneous material considered is inspired of shale formations containing heterogeneity inclusions which are parallel bedded fractures filled with calcites called “beef” (Figure 1).

Shale-Beef    Beef-details

      (a)                                                                  (b)

Figure 1 : (a) Calcite bed inclusions (“beef”) surrounded by mudstone in a shale formation, (b) details of the zone selected for the numerical model

 

Numerical determination of the equivalent or homogenized toughness of these materials needs modeling fracture propagation under external forces. To this purpose a Finite Element model for a representative volume is created (Figure 2). A central part where the fracture can propagate has been more finely meshed.

Figure 2 : Initial mesh

Figure 2: Initial mesh of the model

Then, the mesh has been enriched with joint elements placed around all the elements in the central part where the fracture can propagate and also at the interface between the two materials (Figure 3). Cohesive zone models (the 21400 model of the Disroc catalog) have been assigned to the joint elements with different parameters values for the joints in the mudstone, in beef and at the interface  between the two materials (see mesh details on Figure 4).

Fugure 3: Joint Enriched Mesh

Figure 3 : Mesh enriched with joint elements

 

Figure 4: Mesh details

Figure 4 : Details of mesh enrichement with joint elements

 

The load applied on the model consists in displacements ux imposed on two points (Figure 3):

ux(A)= -1,            ux(B)= 1

when the condition uy = 0 is imposed on all the bottom side of the model.

This loading makes a fracture propagate through the model. The Figure 5 presents the ux displacement field of the model at some stage of fracturing. The figure 6 shows the stress sxx and the Figure 7 the normal stress sn on joint elements. Theses stresses are maximum at the fracture tip.

Figure5 : Displacement 

Figure 5 : The displacement field ux in the fractured model

            Figure6 -Stress_xx 

Figure 6: The normal stress sxx is maximum at the fracture tip

 

By clicking on the result one can see the video-animation which shows an interesting phenomenon: an acceletation of the propagation and even instabilities (jumps) when passing from the harder medium (beef) to the softer one (mudstone).

Simulations of this type make it possible to identify the equivalent toughness or energy release rate for the homogenized medium by calculating the dissipation as the difference between the external work applied on the domain's boundary and the elastic energy stored in the domain. The following figure displays the force-displacement for this loading. The Ux displacement is applied on four nodes on the boundary at the right and four nodes at the left of the crack intersection point on the boundary. The nodal forces Fx for these nodes is given by dahsed-lines on Fig. 7a, and their by the thicker line. The curve shows well the instable propagation intervals leading to sudden force drops making the curve discontinuous. The positions of the crack-tip at these discontinuity instants is given on the Fig. 7b. The instable propagation of the crack at these instants can be well seen on the video of Fig.6.

Force-Displacement Curve Fig.7a: Force-Displacement curve for crack propagation with different instability instants Crack Positions Fig.7b: Crack positions at differents instants


In a second experience, the strength of the beef-mudstone interface was decreased and this caused the propagation of the fracture on this boundary instead of penetrating in the beef (Figure 8 & 9).

Figure : Joint normal stress

  Figure 8: The normal stress sn on the joint elements is maximum at the fracture tip 

Fisgure: Boundary Fracture Propagation

Figure 9: The fracture propagation on the beef-mudstone interface

This shows also the capability of DISROC to simulate fracture propagation in already fractured media.  As a matter of fact, the strength of the joint elements on the beef-mudstone interface could be decreased to zero in order to represent an existing fracture.

The videos showing the fracture propagation can be found by clicking on images.